Since the discovery of the degenerative brain disease chronic traumatic encephalopathy nearly two decades ago, there’s been growing concern among people who play sports and those who allow their children to play sports. The more we know, the more worries there are about the long-term effects of the rough play that goes hand-in-hand with football, soccer, hockey, and the like, so parents are wondering whether their kids should be allowed on the field at all.
Though many unanswered questions remain, preliminary findings presented recently by the Radiological Society of North America seem to point toward the concerns being well-founded – the brain scans of youths who played football changed over the course of just one season.
The researchers used MRI methods to study nerve bundles in the brains of 26 young male football players whose average age was 12, and also included 26 young males who did not play football. Only the nerve fibers in the players brains changed in the before and after scans.
The lead study author, Jeongchul Kim, explains further:
“We applied here two different imaging approaches. One analyzed the shape of the nerve fibers and the other focused on the integrity of the nerves.”
They found some nerve bundles grew longer and others shorter, but no changes were found at all in their integrity. The results suggest that repeated blows to the head could change the shape of players’ corpus callosum, the part of the brain responsible for cognitive, motor, and sensory function communication between the halves of the brain.
For children, this is even more concerning since their brains are continuing to develop.
Study co-author Christopher Whitlow, puts their research into context:
“You have to understand that the NFL players were also most likely once collegiate players, they were also high school players, and they were also probably youth players. To us, it’s more than a question about concussions, it’s a question about long-term cumulative exposure.”
The findings are part of a years-long research collaboration between University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Wake Forest University, and Children’s National Health System in Washington D.C., but they haven’t yet been published in a peer-reviewed journal, though the team is working on a paper for submission.
To that end, the study’s authors and participants caution that the latest findings are only a piece of the puzzle.
“We don’t know what it means,” Whitlow tells NPR. “The natural next question is, do these changes persist over time? Do they accumulate with multiple seasons? And then No. 3, probably the most important: Do they have any relevance to long-term health?”
More information is needed, but proceed with caution, to say the least. You only get one brain, and it seems to be it’s not as hard to damage as we’d like to think.